The following appeared in a memo from the director of a large group of hospitals.
"In a laboratory study of liquid antibacterial hand soaps, a concentrated solution of UltraClean produced a 40 percent greater reduction in the bacteria population than did the liquid hand soaps currently used in our hospitals. During a subsequent test of UltraClean at our hospital in Workby, that hospital reported significantly fewer cases of patient infection than did any of the other hospitals in our group.Therefore, to prevent serious patient infections, we should supply UltraClean at all hand-washing stations throughout our hospital system."
Write a response in which you examine the stated and/or unstated assumptions of the argument. Be sure to explain how the argument depends on these assumptions and what the implications are for the argument if the assumptions prove unwarranted.
The director of a large group of hospitals argues for using Ultraclean at all hand-washing stations throughout his hospital system. He supports it with help of a laboratory test and subsequent test of Ultraclean at one one of his hospitals. However, there are a number of assumptions made which need to be critically analyzed before concluding that argument is sound.
Firstly, there is assumption that greater reduction of bacterial population is enough indication of greater efficacy. It may be that ultraclean is much difficult to use than traditional liquid antibacterial soaps. The bottle that contains it may be much difficult to squeeze and thereby put off the patients from using the solution multiple number of times. This in turn means it has much less efficiency as patients are unwilling to use it. There is no evidence of ease of use of solution and thereby rendering the assumption suspect and unwarranted.
Secondly, there is the assumption that it is ultraclean which is responsible for fewer cases of patient infections in Workby as compared to other hospitals. This is misinterpreting correlation as causation. Just because Ultraclean was used during that period does not mean it alone is responsible for the improvement. There could be other reasons like the hospital would have made efforts for increasing patient awareness about proper cleaning to prevent infections and the patients may be unaware of new product and still used the old liquid antibacterial hand soaps. There is no evidence presented to preclude the other reasons and furthermore there is no evidence that patients did use Ultraclean. Without them, the assumption becomes unwarranted and the argument becomes flawed.
Thirdly, even if the above assumption is true and the Ultraclean was effective in reducing patient infections, the argument makes further assumption that this ensures its effectiveness against serious patient infections. There is no evidence presented that proves that ultraclean is effective against serious patient infections.It may be that it only useful for minor infections. Thus, the assumption becomes unwarranted. This makes argument to use it in all other hospitals for serious infections unsound.
In conclusion, there are a number of assumptions made which need more evidence in order for them to be warranted. Otherwise, the argument rests on tenuous grounds.
- The following appeared in a letter to the editor of the Balmer Island Gazette."The population on Balmer Island increases to 100,000 during the summer months. T oreduce the number of accidents involving mopeds and pedestrians, the town council ofBalmer Isl 80
- The following is a letter to the editor of an environmental magazine Two studies of amphibians in Xanadu National Park confirm a significant decline in the numbers of amphibians In 1975 there were seven species of amphibians in the park and there were abu 50
- A recent study indicates that children living in the Himalayan mountain region in Nepal have lower levels of tooth decay than children living in suburban areas in the United States, despite the fact that people in the Himalayan mountain region in Nepal re 50
- The following recommendation was made by the president and administrative staff of Grove College, a private institution, to the college's governing committee."We recommend that Grove College preserve its centuryold tradition of allfemale education rat 40
- Evidence suggests that academic honor codes, which call for students to agree not to cheat in their academic endeavors and to notify a faculty member if they suspect that others have cheated, are far more successful than are other methods at deterring che 70
----------------
argument 1 -- not OK. You guess:
The bottle that contains it may be much difficult to squeeze and thereby put off the patients from using the solution multiple number of times.
suggested:
A 40 percent greater reduction in the bacteria population maybe because of the high concentration used. If the normal UltraClean is used instead then there could be no reduction in bacteria population.
argument 2 -- OK
argument 3 -- not OK.
'Therefore, to prevent serious patient infections, we should supply UltraClean at all hand-washing stations throughout our hospital system.'
suggested:
There are other factors that lead to the serious infections like immunity or food.
----------------
Attribute Value Ideal
Final score: ? out of 6
Category: Poor Excellent
No. of Grammatical Errors: 0 2
No. of Spelling Errors: 0 2
No. of Sentences: 20 15
No. of Words: 373 350
No. of Characters: 1972 1500
No. of Different Words: 175 200
Fourth Root of Number of Words: 4.395 4.7
Average Word Length: 5.287 4.6
Word Length SD: 2.95 2.4
No. of Words greater than 5 chars: 148 100
No. of Words greater than 6 chars: 131 80
No. of Words greater than 7 chars: 96 40
No. of Words greater than 8 chars: 66 20
Use of Passive Voice (%): 0 0
Avg. Sentence Length: 18.65 21.0
Sentence Length SD: 8.163 7.5
Use of Discourse Markers (%): 0.55 0.12
Sentence-Text Coherence: 0.305 0.35
Sentence-Para Coherence: 0.525 0.50
Sentence-Sentence Coherence: 0.094 0.07
Number of Paragraphs: 5 5